Strategy-Led Growth Starts Here✦

Framework

Should I Use an SEO Company?

By October 5th, 2026No Comments
Should I Use an SEO Company?

Google’s AI gave me a perfectly reasonable answer. But I think it started with the wrong question.

Before You Choose an SEO Company, Should You Choose SEO?

I recently asked Google a very simple question:

“Should I use an SEO company?”

Its AI-generated answer was actually pretty good.

It talked about budget.

Time.

Expertise.

The complexity of the website.

SEO tools.

The risks of choosing a poor agency.

It warned against guaranteed rankings, secret methods and ridiculously cheap SEO packages.

All perfectly sensible advice.

It even produced a handy decision matrix explaining when you should use an SEO company and when you might be better doing SEO yourself.

Then one thing caught my attention.

It suggested that having a monthly marketing budget of £800+ was one indication that hiring an SEO company might make sense.

And that’s where I stopped.

Not because £800 is necessarily wrong.

Because without knowing anything about the business, how could £800 possibly be right?

Where Did £800 Come From?

Imagine two businesses.

Business A sells something where an average new customer generates £50 of profit.

Business B sells something where an average customer might be worth £50,000 over their lifetime.

Should they use the same £800 threshold to decide whether SEO makes sense?

Of course not.

Now imagine Business A operates in a market with enormous search demand and relatively weak competition.

Business B operates in a market where hardly anybody searches for what it sells and the few valuable searches that do exist are dominated by huge national brands.

Same question.

Completely different answer.

That’s the problem with starting with:

Can you afford an SEO company?

We’ve skipped something much more important.

Is SEO actually a sensible investment for this business?

Agency or DIY Isn’t the First Decision

Google’s answer effectively gives us two options.

Hire an SEO company.

Or do it yourself.

I’d add a third.

Don’t invest in SEO yet.

Sometimes that is the correct answer.

Perhaps there isn’t enough search demand.

Perhaps the economics don’t work.

Perhaps the competition is too strong for the available budget.

Perhaps your website already has enough traffic and conversion is the real problem.

Perhaps paid search gives us a faster way to test demand.

Perhaps there are more valuable things to fix first.

That’s why I’d never start by asking:

“Who should do the SEO?”

I’d start with:

“Should we be doing SEO at all?”

Only when we’ve answered that does the agency-versus-DIY conversation become useful.

01 — Growth Diagnostic

Most agencies sell activity. We sell clarity.
If this resonates, you probably don’t need tactics, you need a decision framework.

→ See How the Diagnostic Works

The Numbers Have to Come Before the Retainer

Let’s strip SEO back to something much simpler.

People are searching for things.

Some of those people might become your customers.

Our job is to understand whether enough of those people exist, whether we can realistically reach them and whether doing so could make commercial sense.

That’s it.

Before committing to an SEO retainer, I’d want answers to some fairly basic questions.

How Much Demand Actually Exists?

How many people are searching for the products or services you provide?

Not one keyword.

The genuine market around the thing you sell.

If hardly anybody is looking, reaching position one might be a fantastic technical achievement and a terrible business investment.

What Are Those People Actually Looking For?

Search volume alone isn’t enough.

Someone searching:

“What is SEO?”

is very different from someone searching:

“SEO company Lancashire.”

One is learning.

The other may be choosing a supplier.

The intent changes the commercial value of the traffic.

Who Owns the Market Today?

Who’s currently appearing for the searches that matter?

Small regional businesses?

Established specialists?

National brands?

Government websites?

Huge publishers?

Your realistic ability to compete matters.

A £1,000 monthly investment in one market might be perfectly sensible.

In another, it might barely get you onto the pitch.

What Is a Customer Worth?

This is where SEO stops being an SEO conversation.

What’s an average sale worth?

What’s the margin?

Do customers buy once or repeatedly?

What’s their lifetime value?

How many enquiries become customers?

Without understanding those numbers, how can anybody responsibly tell you what an appropriate SEO budget is?

They can’t.

They can tell you what their SEO package costs.

That’s not the same thing.

The 4-to-6-Month Problem

Google’s answer also suggested that businesses may need to pay a monthly retainer for four to six months before seeing a significant return.

Again, that might happen.

But why four to six months?

A well-established website already sitting around positions five to ten could potentially move relatively quickly.

A brand-new website entering an extremely competitive national market could take considerably longer.

SEO doesn’t operate to a universal timetable.

The market decides much of the difficulty.

Your starting position matters.

Your competitors matter.

Your website matters.

Your authority matters.

The resources available matter.

That’s why I’d be very cautious of anybody giving you a timeframe before they’ve looked at any of those things.

This Is Why We Built the Traffic Projection Tool

This frustration is one of the reasons we built our SEO Traffic Projection Tool.

Before talking about retainers, we wanted to answer a much more useful question:

What’s the opportunity?

How much relevant search demand exists?

Who’s capturing it now?

What positions might realistically be achievable?

What sort of traffic could those positions produce?

And crucially:

What might that traffic be worth to the business?

It’s not a promise.

It’s a model.

Sometimes the model makes SEO look extremely attractive.

Sometimes it tells us the opportunity is smaller than the business expected.

Both are useful answers.

Because I’d rather discover that before somebody signs a twelve-month SEO agreement.

Should I Use an SEO Company?

Now We Can Ask Who Should Do It

Let’s assume we’ve done the work.

Demand exists.

The searches have commercial intent.

The competition is realistic.

Customers are valuable enough.

And the potential return justifies the investment.

Great.

Now we can ask whether you need an SEO company.

And at this point, much of Google’s original advice becomes perfectly reasonable.

Do you have the time?

Do you have the expertise?

Do you understand technical SEO?

Can you create genuinely useful content?

Can you interpret Search Console data?

Can you build authority?

Can you identify when something isn’t working?

Can you stay consistent for long enough to give the strategy a chance?

If yes, you might be perfectly capable of doing a considerable amount yourself.

I’ve never believed every business needs an SEO agency.

But there’s another question.

Should you be doing it yourself?

That’s different.

A managing director might be perfectly capable of learning SEO.

They could probably learn Google Ads too.

And WordPress.

And bookkeeping.

And employment law.

And plumbing if they really put their mind to it.

Capability isn’t always the issue.

Time has a value.

So does focus.

Sometimes outsourcing makes sense because expertise produces a better result.

Sometimes it makes sense because your time is better spent doing something else.

And sometimes it doesn’t make sense at all.

That’s the decision we’re trying to make.

Cheap SEO Isn’t Automatically Bad. Expensive SEO Isn’t Automatically Good.

I’d also challenge another part of the standard agency conversation.

Price alone tells you very little.

A £250 SEO package isn’t automatically rubbish because it’s cheap.

A £5,000 retainer isn’t automatically sophisticated because it’s expensive.

The question is:

What is being done, why is it being done, and what commercial opportunity is it pursuing?

If somebody can genuinely create a return for £250, fantastic.

If a £5,000 investment can reliably pursue an opportunity worth £100,000, that might be fantastic too.

Context.

Again.

The numbers have to make sense.

No Guarantees Doesn’t Mean No Accountability

Google’s AI was absolutely right about one thing.

Nobody legitimate should guarantee you position one.

There are too many variables outside an agency’s control.

But I don’t think “SEO has no guarantees” should become an excuse for avoiding accountability either.

An agency should still be able to explain:

What it’s targeting.

Why those searches matter.

Where you’re starting.

What it’s changing.

What the data is telling us.

Whether the opportunity still stacks up.

And what we’ll do if the original assumptions prove wrong.

That’s not guaranteeing an outcome.

It’s being accountable for the decisions.

There’s a big difference.

One Final Thought

So…

Should you use an SEO company?

Maybe.

But that’s not the question I’d start with.

Before choosing an agency…

Before comparing retainers…

Before worrying about backlinks…

Before asking how long SEO takes…

Find out whether the opportunity deserves your money.

How many people are looking?

What are they looking for?

Who currently owns that demand?

Can you realistically compete?

What would winning some of that demand be worth?

Only then should you decide how much to invest and who should do the work.

Because the biggest SEO mistake isn’t choosing the wrong agency.

It’s investing in SEO before you’ve established whether SEO was the right decision in the first place.

Froogle Principle

Before asking who should do your SEO, establish whether SEO deserves your money.

Everything else comes afterwards.

author avatar
Stephen Harvey Founder